| Engineering and fixture design | 15% | Can design around part tolerances, weld sequence, access, distortion control, and operator ergonomics. For complex projects, review tolerance stack-up and datum strategy before design release. | Design review records, 3D CAD model, tolerance analysis, weld-access assessment, and documented design revisions. |
| Manufacturing accuracy and build quality | 15% | Demonstrates measurement and inspection methods suited to the fixture’s required locating and clamping tolerances. Confirm acceptance criteria are agreed before fabrication. | Inspection plan, dimensional inspection report, calibration records for measurement equipment, and fixture acceptance checklist. |
| Welding-process knowledge | 12% | Understands the specified process—such as MIG/MAG, TIG, resistance spot, or laser welding—and accounts for torch or electrode clearance, spatter, heat input, and weld sequence. | Process-specific project examples, welding-access review, clearance checks, and documented input from welding-process engineers. |
| Repeatability and part-location strategy | 12% | Uses defined datums, suitable locating features, and a repeatable loading method. Validate repeatability with production-representative parts and the customer’s measurement method. | Datum and locator scheme, repeatability study, sample-part inspection results, and measurement-system details. |
| Project execution and delivery | 10% | Provides a clear schedule covering design approval, fabrication, tryout, corrections, and shipment. Assess delivery performance against the supplier’s stated commitments. | Project schedule, milestone reporting format, recent on-time delivery data, and escalation process for schedule risks. |
| Tryout, validation, and documentation | 10% | Supports fit-up and production trials, records open issues, and confirms agreed acceptance criteria before final handover. | Tryout plan, issue log, corrective-action records, acceptance report, and as-built documentation package. |
| Serviceability and spare parts | 8% | Designs for routine inspection and replacement of wear items, clamps, locators, and sensors. Confirm spare-part identification and maintenance instructions. | Recommended-spares list, maintenance instructions, component specifications, and service-response process. |
| Automation and controls integration | 7% | Where applicable, can coordinate fixture interfaces with robots, sensors, safety devices, and plant controls. Verify signal definitions and safety responsibilities early. | Interface documents, I/O list, sensor and clamp specifications, safety review records, and integration test plan. |
| Quality and change management | 6% | Maintains documented inspection, nonconformance, corrective-action, and engineering-change processes. Check that revisions are traceable through design and build records. | Quality-system documentation, sample change record, nonconformance workflow, and traceability procedure. |
| Commercial transparency and lifecycle cost | 5% | Provides a clear quotation that separates tooling, design, tryout, shipping, installation, and optional support where relevant. Compare total lifecycle cost, not only initial price. | Itemized quotation, assumptions and exclusions, warranty terms, payment milestones, and proposed lifecycle support costs. |