| Product quality and consistency | Fit, grip strength, adjustment range, material finish, and consistency between samples and production units. | Production-representative samples, inspection records, approved specifications, and a written defect-handling process. | Compare samples with the agreed specification; define acceptable defects and inspection criteria before placing an order. | 20% |
| Design and vehicle compatibility | Mounting type, phone-size range, case compatibility, viewing-angle adjustment, and installation requirements. | Dimensioned drawings, compatibility list, installation instructions, and sample testing in representative vehicles or setups. | Confirm the holder suits the intended vehicle interior and target phone range; treat compatibility claims as requiring verification. | 12% |
| Material and component control | Plastic or metal specifications, coatings, adhesives, magnets, springs, and other components used in the product. | Bill of materials, material specifications, incoming-inspection procedures, and applicable test reports. | Check that material and component descriptions match the approved sample and the product’s intended use. | 12% |
| Quality management | Documented inspection stages, traceability, corrective actions, and handling of customer complaints. | Quality-management certificate, if claimed; certificate scope and validity; inspection checklists; corrective-action examples. | Verify certificates with the issuing organization where possible. A certificate alone does not establish product quality. | 14% |
| Manufacturing capacity | Available production equipment, staffing, process capability, current workload, and ability to meet the requested schedule. | Factory audit or live production review, equipment list, production plan, and capacity figures tied to the specific product and shift pattern. | Ask how quoted capacity is calculated and whether it is available during the requested production window. | 14% |
| Order and delivery readiness | Minimum order quantity, lead time, production scheduling, packaging readiness, and shipment coordination. | Written quotation, order confirmation, production milestones, packaging specification, and shipping-document checklist. | Compare the supplier’s written commitment with your order volume and required delivery date; clarify what starts the lead-time clock. | 10% |
| Compliance and product documentation | Applicable destination-market requirements, labeling, warnings, and documentation for any powered or electronic features. | Relevant test reports or declarations, product labels, user instructions, and evidence that documents cover the exact product model. | Requirements depend on product design and destination market. Confirm applicable rules with a qualified compliance professional. | 8% |
| Communication and change control | Response clarity, escalation contacts, approval workflow, and control of changes to materials, design, or production process. | Named project contact, written change-approval procedure, sample-approval record, and documented order updates. | Assess responsiveness during sampling and quotation; require written approval before material or specification changes. | 5% |
| Commercial transparency | Unit pricing, tooling or setup charges, payment terms, warranty scope, and costs for packaging or customization. | Itemized quotation, warranty terms, payment schedule, and written explanation of any additional charges. | Compare quotations on the same specification and delivery basis rather than unit price alone. | 5% |
Total suggested evaluation weight Weights are a buyer-use scorecard framework, not measured market statistics. | 100% |