| 1 | Fiber sourcing and traceability | Fiber type and percentage by product: virgin pulp, recycled fiber, or other fiber. Ask for the origin and traceability scope for each pulp grade. | Purchase records, pulp specifications, mill or supplier declarations, and a valid chain-of-custody certificate where certified material is claimed. | Check that product claims match the certificate scope, transaction documents, and the material used for the quoted product. |
| 2 | Certification and environmental claims | Certificate standard, certificate holder, covered sites, product scope, certificate status, and the exact environmental claim used on the product. | Verify certificates with the relevant certification scheme’s public database or issuing body. For self-declared claims, request substantiation and clear definitions. | Treat a certificate as evidence only within its valid scope. ISO 14021 provides principles for self-declared environmental claims; it is not a product certification. |
| 3 | Water withdrawal and consumption | Annual water withdrawal and consumption, reported separately where available; production volume; water intensity in m³ per tonne; and the reporting period. | Meter records, site water balance, utility bills, production records, and a written description of the reporting boundary and calculation method. | Compare suppliers only when product type, site boundary, production denominator, and reporting period are consistent. Do not confuse withdrawal with consumption. |
| 4 | Water footprint and wastewater | Water-footprint assessment method, wastewater volume, treatment route, and available monitoring results for relevant discharge parameters. | Assessment report, wastewater treatment records, discharge monitoring reports, and applicable permits or compliance records for the production site. | Check the assessment boundary and method. ISO 14046 sets principles, requirements, and guidelines for water-footprint assessment; site results still require context. |
| 5 | Energy and greenhouse-gas data | Energy use per tonne of tissue, energy sources, and greenhouse-gas emissions with the stated gases, organizational boundary, and reporting period. | Utility and fuel records, calculation methodology, emissions factors, and any independent assurance statement. | Use the same product and site boundaries and distinguish measured data from estimates. Do not compare figures with different scopes as if they were equivalent. |
| 6 | Packaging materials and recyclability | Packaging material types and weights per sales unit, recycled-content percentage where claimed, and packaging components such as films, labels, and cartons. | Packaging specifications, supplier declarations, bills of materials, and supporting records for recycled-content claims. | Compare packaging weight per equivalent product quantity. Assess recyclability for the destination market, since collection and recycling access vary by location. |
| 7 | Product quality and test methods | Basis weight (g/m²), sheet or roll dimensions, ply, tensile strength, absorbency, softness, and lint or dust data where relevant to the product. | Current product specification, batch test reports, sampling plan, and named test methods. The ISO 12625 series includes test methods for tissue paper and tissue products. | Compare like-for-like products tested using the same methods and conditioning. Confirm that the tested sample matches the product offered. |
| 8 | Chemical and hygiene controls | Applicable chemical restrictions, process-chemical controls, hygiene criteria, and any market-specific product requirements. | Risk assessments, supplier declarations, relevant laboratory reports, and documented production hygiene controls. | Agree on applicable limits and test methods for the intended market and product use; avoid relying on unsupported “chemical-free” claims. |
| 9 | Factory environmental management | Production-site details, environmental permits, environmental incidents, corrective actions, and the status and scope of any management-system certification. | Site audit records, permit documentation, corrective-action logs, and verification of any ISO 14001 certificate with the certification body. | Confirm that the audited or certified site is the actual manufacturing location for the product, not merely a sales office or unrelated facility. |
| 10 | Batch consistency and document control | Batch or lot identification, certificate-of-analysis availability, specification revision, complaint rate, and change-notification process. | Recent batch records, retained-sample procedure, quality-control logs, complaint and corrective-action records, and a sample purchase order or shipment document. | Cross-check product codes, lot numbers, specifications, and environmental claims across samples, quotations, test reports, and shipping documents. |